Since the introduction of torsional ultrasound in 2006, many surgeons around the world have embraced the enhanced efficiency of the side-toside cutting movement of the phaco tip created by torsional ultrasound technology. I predicted at the introduction of the Ozil torsional ultrasound handpiece (Alcon Laboratories, Inc.) that this new technology would revolutionize cataract surgery.1-6
The torsional ultrasound modality causes the phaco tip to rotate slightly around its axis, inducing a twist that results in a significant sideways displacement of the phaco tip end. Figure 1 is a simplistic geometric approximation of the actual tip motion.
COMPARISON OF CUTTING EFFECTIVENESS
The phaco tip end displacement is dependent on the degree of asymmetry of the tip shaft. A straight tip induces very little phaco tip displacement. As the angle of the bend increases, more movement of the phaco tip cutting end occurs.
Current phaco tips are available with12° or 20° bends. The 12° tip is favored by surgeons who are used to straight tips, but it has approximately 30% less tip end movement than the 20° bend tip.
Reducing the tip diameter and/or tip wall thickness also augments phaco tip cutting edge displacement. The miniflared phaco tips, which are commonly used for microcoaxial phaco, show increased cutting efficiency compared with the thicker tapered and micro tips.
All tips are available with either 30° or 45° bevels; however, the 45° variety excels with torsional phacoemulsification. Its sharper tip provides enhanced cutting, especially during nucleus sculpting. The larger opening of a 45° tip also removes a softer nucleus more rapidly because greater holding force on the nucleus occurs during tip occlusion.
The greater bevel may also induce more repositioning of dense lens material on the tip. This prevents coring of the nucleus and, therefore, the need to frequently reposition lens material with a second instrument. The increased cutting of lens material may reduce the possibility of tip obstruction.7
FLARED TIP DESIGN AND PROLONGED OCCLUSION
The oscillatory movement of the torsional tip is highly effective in shaving lens material. When a flared tip design is used, the mechanism does not cause aspirated material to be jackhammered into and through the tip, as with traditional longitudinal phacoemulsification. Therefore, it is important for the material to be broken up into relatively small pieces that can pass through the lumen of the tip without obstructing it. If torsional vibration is interrupted, or if larger fragments of dense lens material enter the lumen, obstruction may result. Periods of prolonged tip occlusion halt the shaving process and decrease the tip’s efficiency.
The advantage of a bigger port opening is an increased holding surface and therefore holding power of the phaco tip. With flared tips, the larger port opening narrows into a smaller size lumen shaft, which reduces surge upon occlusion break. This type of flared phaco tip is particularly advantageous when using longitudinal ultrasound technology, in which high vacuum and aspiration flow settings are necessary to overcome the repelling effect of the longitudinal movement of the phaco tip. With torsional ultrasound, lower fluidics settings are safer and more effective.8,9
A NONFLARED TIP DESIGN FOR MICROCOAXIAL PHACO
Flared tips repeatedly undergo brief periods of prolonged occlusion, especially with denser nuclei. This can sometimes necessitate retraction of the phaco handpiece to liberate the tip from nuclear material.
Recently, a small nonflared tip has been introduced. The size of the 0.9 Mini Tip (Alcon Laboratories, Inc.) shaft lumen (570 μm) is identical to that of the mini-flared tip. The outside diameter of the 0.9 Mini Tip is slightly smaller than the mini-flared tip at 800 μm versus 830 μm (Figure 2).
The slightly thinner wall is probably responsible for the slightly increased cutting edge tip displacement. During clinical evaluation, I found that the 0.9 Mini Tip performed very well and did not show any significant prolonged occlusion, therefore enhancing overall cutting efficiency, especially in denser nuclei. For a video demonstration, visit eyetube.net/?v=wogof. The smaller port size theoretically leads to reduced holding force, but in clinical use this has not been a factor for me.
A comparison of the performance of several tip designs is shown in Table 1.
The 0.9 Mini Tip is the first phaco tip designed specifically for torsional ultrasound. The nonflared design prevents inadvertent prolonged occlusion, which in turn prevents unwanted temperature increase, as the phaco tip is sufficiently cooled by the aspiration flow. This new phaco tip shows a noticeably enhanced cutting efficiency on dense nuclei, but it is suitable for all densities. I highly recommend this new phaco tip for routine use with torsional ultrasound.
Khiun F. Tjia, MD, is an Anterior Segment Specialist at the Isala Clinics, Zwolle, Netherlands. Dr. Tjia states that he is a consultant to Alcon Laboratories, Inc. He is the Co- Chief Medical Editor of CRST Europe. Dr. Tjia may be reached at e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org.
- Tjia K.Torsional lens removal technology.Presented at:XXIII Congress of the ESCRS;September 13,2005;Lisbon, Portugal.
- Tjia K.Total cataract removal procedure through a 2.0-2.2 mm incision using new torsional lens removal technology and new smaller sleeves.Presented at:XXIII Congress of the ESCRS;September 13,2005;Lisbon,Portugal.
- Tjia K.Trends in phacoemulsification.Ophthalmology Times Europe.2005;1(1):32-34.
- Tjia K.Efficiency of torsional versus longitudinal ultrasound.Cataract & Refractive Surgery Today Europe. 2008;3(4):33-34.
- Tjia K.Microcoaxial phacoemulsification:a new standard in cataract surgery? Cataract & Refractive Surgery Today Europe.2006;1(2):18-20.
- Tjia K.Routine use of microcoaxial torsional phaco.Cataract & Refractive Surgery Today Europe.2007;2(1):14-16.
- Allen D.Comparison of efficiency of 30° and 45° Mini-Flared Kelman tips during torsional phacoemulsification. Presented at:XXV Congress of the ESCRS;September 8,2007;Stockholm,Sweden.
- Johansson C.Optimizing vacuum settings in torsional ultrasound phacoemulsification.Cataract & Refractive Surgery Today Europe.2008;3(4):24-27.
- Tjia K.A low fluidics parameters strategy.Cataract & Refractive Surgery Today Europe.2007;2(2):52-53.